Initial reactions to Bush's speech
- Once again, Bush did not say much of any substance. This speech was supposed to outline the plan for "Victory in Iraq" (that's the White House's title, not mine), but instead it was once again mostly about "See what a good job we have done in Iraq," and "We will not cut and run."
- Bush said that people complaining that we have not learned lessons and applied them in Iraq are "flat wrong." As evidence, he noted that the military commanders on the ground have adapted and are adapting their tactics. The problem is NOT with the military commanders on the ground. The problem is with the civilian leaders--most notably Bush and Rumskull. As I have explained in detail (Official campaign planning doctrine and the post-war period, A note on the applicability of JP 5-00.1, and More on the principles in JP 5.00-1), Bush and Rumskull have always been primarily responsible for determining the long-range overall goals and strategies to achieve those goals. The military commanders on the ground are dealing with the day-to-day realities of combat and survival. Those factors are not the same as setting the overall goals and strategies for "Victory in Iraq."
- A quick review of the executive summary of "Victory in Iraq" (which was necessary since the speech did not really discuss the plan) shows that this is the type of planning that should have been done BEFORE THE WAR EVER STARTED. Instead, it comes FOUR FREAKIN' YEARS LATER.
- Bush also said that Iraq would not become another Afghanistan. News flash for you, George: in some ways Iraq is Afghanistan of the past. Many Al Qaeda leaders learned and honed their violent skills in Afghanistan during the Soviet occupation. It was a real-life combat training ground. Under the Taliban, Afghanistan was still a training ground, but there was no actual combat. Iraq is now the real-life combat training ground. Terrorists are learning and honing skills in a way that did not exist after the Soviets left Afghanistan and before we invaded Iraq. Now the terrorists do not have to go to the trouble and expense of supporting a regime like the Taliban because we are providing the training ground for free.
- Once again, Bush singled out one soldier killed in Iraq in a speech. And he still has not attended even one funeral or memorial service for anyone killed in Iraq.